Science Reasoning: Teach Students to Argue Like Scientists
STEM Tools
How science reasoning gives kids a powerful voice
In today’s world, knowing how to make strong, evidence-based arguments is an essential skill—not just for academic success but for life. The ability to reason clearly and back up ideas with evidence gives kids a sense of agency and power. It’s their foundation for engaging in meaningful conversations, solving problems, and advocating for themselves and others… Reasoning science.
Yet, many students need help with this skill. They might say, “I just know it’s true,” or, “It’s what I think,” but those explanations reveal a gap: they don’t know how to support their ideas with evidence. This challenge isn’t just about academics; it’s about empowering students with the tools to think critically, reason deeply, and communicate effectively. A solution is to introduce the process of claim, evidence, reasoning to build science reasoning skills.
Reasoning science for elementary students can be taught with: claim, evidence, and reasoning (CER). It equips students with transferable skills they’ll use in all areas of life. It’s also the backbone of science, where making sense of the world requires connecting observations to conclusions. If we want kids to thrive, we must teach them how to gather evidence, evaluate it, and confidently explain their reasoning. Learn more.
When the status quo for reasoning science is a problem
Too often, traditional teaching methods don’t equip students with these skills. Asking students to “support your answer with evidence” without modeling how to do it is like handing them a jigsaw puzzle without showing them the picture. Lectures and worksheets fall short of sparking curiosity or teaching the art of reasoning science.
If we want students to think like scientists or persuasive leaders, they need meaningful opportunities to practice. That means gathering evidence, linking it to their claims, and presenting well-reasoned arguments. This skill-building is critical—not just for science but for navigating life.
PBL: A reasoning science or evidenced-based thinking launchpad
Project-Based Learning (PBL) is a game-changer for teaching kids how to connect ideas with evidence. Instead of passively absorbing information, students dive into real-world challenges and actively engage in discovery.
For instance, consider a project where students explore local ecosystems to determine the best ways to attract pollinators. They’ll research, observe, collect data, and test hypotheses. Then, when they present their findings, they’ll need to connect their claims with the evidence they’ve gathered. Students learn organically how to build strong arguments through projects like this, just like scientists.
PBL doesn’t just teach content—it transforms the way students think. By immersing them in real-world contexts, they gain practice in collecting and analyzing data, reasoning through challenges, and communicating their ideas effectively.
Bring reasoning science to the center stage
You don’t need to overhaul your entire curriculum to get started. Start small by choosing a relevant question that resonates with your students. Guide them through gathering data, even if it’s imperfect or messy. Challenge them to explain their reasoning during discussions or presentations: “Why do you think that? What’s your evidence?”
Celebrate when a student confidently says, “I know this because….” That moment signals growth—not just in their reasoning but also in their confidence and ability to make their voice heard.
Ready to empower your students and transform your teaching? Try PBL and watch as your classroom becomes a space where students grow into confident thinkers, one evidence-based argument at a time.
You must be logged in to post a comment.